• Home
  • /
  • Insights
  • /
  • Why Content Fails When You Don’t Know the Buyer’s Bigger Story

Joe Pulizzi named this problem before most teams were ready to hear it. Most B2B content fails because it’s built around the company’s story, not the buyer’s — and that hasn’t changed.

Published: June 2, 2025  
Updated: March 19, 2026

min read

Why this still matters: Long before “buyer-first,” “empathy,” or “trust-based marketing” became fashionable GTM language, Joe Pulizzi’s keynote surfaced the same problem teams are still tripping over today.

Most B2B content fails because it’s built around the company, not the buyer.

The tools have changed. The dashboards have multiplied. The problem hasn’t moved an inch.

If you’re modernizing your GTM motion, this post connects directly to how buyer-journey content should actually be designed now — not as campaigns, but as context-driven help. (Related: Buyer Intent Over Clicks: Two Questions That Drive Engagement)

Quick Answer

Content fails when it focuses on what you sell instead of the problem your buyer is trying to solve.

Buyers don’t engage with content because it’s clever or polished. They engage because it reflects their reality, their challenges, and the bigger story they’re already living inside.

Key Takeaways

  • Your buyer is the story. Products are supporting characters.
  • Industry “boring” is a myth. Every market has a passion point if you look beyond features.
  • Great content comes from listening, not brainstorming.
  • The bigger story fuels nurturing. Engagement compounds when content reflects buyer curiosity.
  • Employees amplify what feels real. Authentic stories travel farther internally and externally.

The Question Marketers Keep Asking (and Getting Wrong)

“Anybody here think you have nothing to create content around? No exciting stories to tell?”

Joe Pulizzi has heard this question for years, especially from B2B teams in industrial and manufacturing spaces.

Metal-working manufacturers asked him the same thing:

“What do we talk about?”

The assumption hiding underneath that question is dangerous:

“If our product isn’t exciting, our content can’t be either.”

Joe’s response reframed the entire issue:

“Your customers don’t care about you. They don’t care about your products. They care about solving a problem.”

That single sentence explains why most content strategies stall.

The Bigger Story Principle

Joe illustrated this idea using a now-classic B2B example: Maersk Group

On paper, Maersk is not a “content brand.” They ship containers. Globally. That’s it.

And yet, they built one of the most engaged B2B audiences in the world.

  • Over 1.5 million Facebook followers (now more than 1.8M)
  • Tens of thousands of likes, shares, and comments
  • Strong LinkedIn engagement that fed directly into nurturing

How?

They stopped talking about shipping services and started talking about what their buyers cared about.

The bigger story: How strange, massive, and fascinating things move around the world.

Weird cargo. Unusual containers. Incredible logistics challenges.

That’s what their customers were already obsessed with.

So were their employees. All 120,000 of them.


Watch the Keynote Excerpt

One of Joe’s most pointed challenges still lands hard today:

“Do you really know the pain points of your buyer persona — and what the bigger story could be?”

Content doesn’t work because it’s creative.

It works because it mirrors how buyers already think about their world.

Why This Matters for Lead Nurturing and GTM Systems

This isn’t just a content marketing lesson. It’s a GTM systems lesson.

Maersk didn’t stop at social engagement. They used content as a bridge:

  • Prospects were invited into ongoing conversations
  • LinkedIn became a nurturing environment, not a promotion channel
  • Content reduced friction before a sales conversation ever started

This is where most teams miss the point.

Buyer-journey content isn’t about pushing messages. It’s about creating places buyers want to stay while they figure things out.

What the Transcript Reveals (That Strategy Slides Don’t)

Reading the transcript makes something obvious that slides often hide:

You don’t find the bigger story by guessing.

Joe’s advice was blunt:

You won’t uncover it through “social listening dashboards” alone.

You find it by:

  • Talking to customers
  • Asking what they obsess over
  • Noticing what they share when no one is selling

Maersk didn’t invent a story.

They discovered one their buyers already loved.

How to Apply This to Your Own Content

If you’re stuck wondering what to create, start here:

  • What problems do buyers talk about when you’re not in the room?
  • What parts of their job frustrate, fascinate, or challenge them?
  • What do your best customers forward internally?

The bigger story usually sits adjacent to your product, not inside it.

That’s uncomfortable for teams measured on “product messaging.”

It’s also why the content that works doesn’t feel like marketing.

Bottom Line

Content fails when it’s designed to explain you.

It succeeds when it helps buyers make sense of their world.

If your content strategy starts with “what should we say,” it’s already off track.

Start with the bigger story your buyer is living inside.

Everything else gets easier after that.

You might also like:

Get GTM Clarity Updates 

Short, practical emails on buyer friction, lead management, and GTM system issues that slow revenue.

💡No hype. No noise. Clarity your team can actually use.

Brian Carroll is the founder of Markempa, host of the B2B Roundtable Podcast, and author of Lead Generation for the Complex Sale (McGraw-Hill). He is a Certified GTM OS Partner and runs the GTM Clarity Roundtable, a community of 20,000+ B2B sales, marketing, and GTM professionals.

Brian works with leadership teams at established B2B companies with complex sales to identify what’s limiting growth, align on what to fix, and help their teams make the change.

Subscribe to Brian’s GTM Clarity Newsletter on LinkedIn